On May 25th, 2002 the Sifrits both 24 at the time they met a couple while vacationing in Ocean City, Maryland. They were Joshua Ford and Martha Crutchley. After going out and partying at a local bar the Sifrit’s invited them back to their rented condo. According to court records. The couple invited them back to their rental condo and then killed them. There are also rumours BJ sat in a hot tub with Ford’s and Crutchley’s heads floating in it.
After luring the couple into their rental they claimed that Erika’s purse was stolen. This was after a night when they befriended them. BJ then pulled a gun on Ford and shot him in the bathroom 4 times. Crutchley was stabbed to death. They hucked their remains in dumpsters all over town.
Erika Elaine Sifrit (née Grace; born February 3, 1978) in Roaring Spring, Pennsylvania is currently going to spend the rest of her life in jail. She is in Patuxent Institution in Jessup, Maryland. She is an only child born to a very well to do off family. She was an honor student and basketball star at Mary Washington College. Her and Ben married in 1998 at 20 years old. After her and Ben married they opened up a Scrapbook store in Erika’s home town of Altoona, Pennsylvania.
Benjamin Adam “BJ” Sifrit (born October 21, 1977): Is a former marine who is probably currently at his new home he has at Roxburry Correctional Facility in Hagerstown, Maryland.